Days in advance, we purchased tickets for a tour of Robben Island, considered a 'must-do' while in Cape Town. Robben Island is a prison island, much larger than Alcatraz and 8 miles from Cape Town, but also rocky and fairly arid. Robben Island became famous as the prison for South African political prisoners during apartheid, with the most famous of it's captives being Nelson Mandela, who spent 18 years (of his 27 years in prison) there.
Robben Island has a long history of pain - nearly 400 years - as a prison, leper colony, hospital for the mentally and chronically ill, a place of banishment for those deemed unfit for society, and a place to hold political prisoners. For centuries it was a place to hold native African leaders in attempts by the Dutch and British to quell any uprising against their rule. Conditions were harsh, as Robben Island had no fresh water and marginal capacity for agriculture. Robben Island was thrust into the world spotlight when it became infamous as a prison for political prisoners during apartheid. It was through this time though, that Robben Island came to symbolize human triumph over adversity.
So, with all of that history, why did the visit to Robben island leave me feeling like I came away with bare impressions of the place and it's place in history? In conversation with Rich and Brad this past weekend, I mentioned that I keep coming up empty when I think of writing about the place.
I think it has to do with the unfortunate conflicting needs of opening the island to many visitors (and revenue) with operating a place to learn about the island, it's history, and apartheid. It might be that my expectation was to do more than briskly visit (and quite possibly that was enough). On disembarking from the ferry at Robben Island, we were all taken to two waiting buses. The buses were driven around the island, with one stop at a rocky point with a good view of Cape Town and Table Mountain (nice, but not why I was there), while a guide talked about the various buildings. We might have seen the quarry where prisoners labored but I'm not sure. At the prison both busloads of people were then taken on a tour at the same time.
Our guide in the prison was a political prisoner for 20 years. He had the unfortunate task of trying to communicate with an enormous number of people while escorting us through narrow passageways, all at the same time. It didn't work very well. Here was a man who had been here, had a wealth of knowledge about the prison and life there, who had to balance conveying this experience with shepherding an enormous number of people through the facility. It was a genuine loss to have his story get lost in the herding of people.
I'm still glad we went. It would have been helpful to have done more homework about the island before going, but having been there puts subsequent research into some perspective. What we didn't have the opportunity to see is the vast amount of archival material about the island, including oral histories, photographs, film and video. I now know that this material is kept at the University of the Western Cape. It was this type of material that made our visit to the Apartheid Museum in Johannesburg so much more valuable as a learning tool and brought more of a human element to the experience.
What was crystal clear from the visit was that life on the island was incredibly harsh for the prisoners. There is great value in being reminded of how fear, exploited by politicians, so often results in brutality against other people. History has a way of repeating itself over and over.
The loudest message from Robben Island is the triumph of human spirit over adversity. Underneath that is the reminder of how perilous it is to chip away at civil liberties until you find yourself living in a society without them.















